Friday, February 24, 2012

The Indifference Principle: Roman Style

When we are considering a happy life, you cannot answer me as though after a division of the House, “This view has most supporters,” because for that very reason it is the worse of the two.  Matters do not stand so well with mankind that the majority should prefer the better course: the more people do a thing the worse it is likely to be.
—Seneca in On a Happy Life

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Costs of Education

We seek no price, O king.  We ask only a fit place for teaching and quick minds to teach, and besides these food and clothing…
—Answer to Charlemagne’s question to two teachers regarding what price they require to take a teaching post.  From Richard Winston in Charlemagne (1960).


Contrast this with today.  I recently sent an email to university administrators volunteering to assemble a Task Force to find ways to manage the rise in tuition.  Of course, it may have been me that repelled them, but I got no reply to my email. This is not illogical.  Why would we care, when the money keeps rolling in no matter what we do?

Intellectuals in Time

Is it not obvious that our contemporary concern with schools of existentialism, say, or with the distinctions among capitalism, communism and socialism, will seem a thousand years hence as incomprehensible to historians of his temper as the eight century’s concern with adoptianism, iconoclasm or the filioque controversy?  The human mind has always worked with the materials it had at hand.  It is risk to judge and condemn the intellectual achievements of one age by the standards of another.  Aristotle was not a fool because he thought the universe consisted of fifty-five concentric hollow spheres—any more than Niels Bohr was a fool when he framed his “solar system” model of the atom…The slower pace of scientific development in the past does not mean that every thinker from Aristotle to Copernicus was an intellectual dwarf.  The modern schoolboy is not greater than Euclid because he knows far more about mathematics.
—Richard Winston in Charlemagne (1960).

Origin of Guilds

The first time the word "guild" was recorded was in 779 when Charlemagne's Frankish kingdom outlawed them, just as he outlawed excessive tolls.

—Richard Winston in Charlemagne (1960).

P.S.  Can you tell which book I have been reading?

Superstitious Farmers in the Early Middle Ages

These peasants were a superstitious lot who clung to many an ancient magic rite, in spite of the warnings of their priests and stewards.  They were filled with awe of the earth.  “They considered the field a living creature which had to be tamed, before cultivation was begun, by magic spells…At the first plowing an egg was laid before the plow; if it broke, the earth was willing to accept the sacrifice…Taboos were observed to guard the health of the earth.  Women who had just given birth and people with lung sicknesses were not permitted to approach the field.  When bodies were taken to the grave, the procession must not cross any cultivated field.”
Every peasant village had its magician who saw to it that the spells were properly observed.  These magicians provided portions and spells for healing sick cows, oxen, chickens and children, and were always obliging about concocting philters to help lovelorn peasant girls win the peasant Tristans. Pagan beliefs died hard; as has often been observed, the Church had to confer on innumerable saints the powers of heathen spirits before the simpler folk could be weaned entirely away from their ancient religion.
Among the more expensive of magic rites was the custom of burying deep in the ground a part of the seed for sowing, as a sacrificial offering to Erda, the goddess of earth, who might otherwise be offended when the peasant rudely drove his plow into her body.  Charles [read: Charlemagne] vainly called on his stewards to stamp out this practice for the eminently sensible reason that it was wasteful: less seed was sown and the harvest was diminished.
—Richard Winston in Charlemagne (1960).

How the pagan gods of Germany was cut down, literally

Germany in middle of the eighth century (722-732 AD) had a sundry of gods nearly identical to ancient Rome, though the gods went by different names.  The Christians of this era felt they were charged to convert the pagans, if not by persuasion, then by force.  Thor the Thunderer resembled Zeus and Jupiter, and Thor was symbolized chiefly by a big oak tree.  Not just any big oak tree: one tree in particular.

Thor was not so mighty though.  Thor was subdued by a simple Benedictine Monk.  Well, maybe not simple.  Boniface was an English missionary who traveled about Europe bringing pagans to Jesus, and he now entered the sacred grove of oak trees of Germany with an ax in his hand.  Walking right up to the enormous oak presumed to be the manifestation of Thor's essence, Boniface chopped it down.  To the pagans' surprise, Thor did not retaliate with his trademark bolt of lightning.

This was done in plain sight of Germans.  Why did they let him destroy their holy tree?  No one knows.  Perhaps they assumed Thor would defend itself?  Perhaps Boniface had soldiers with him?  If chroniclers were more reliable, perhaps we would know.  It is said that many conversions were made that day, marking a rare event when empirical observation swayed people's religious affiliation.

If Thor got his revenge, it was belated.  Boniface was eventually murdered by pagans, but not until 754, more than twenty years after he chopped down Thor.  Since Boniface had to die someday, it would be hard to claim he did so at the hand of Thor.  I would think Thor to have a short fuse, and would not wait long for revenge.

Was Boniface sainted?  Of course.  Killing a pagan god does not go unnoticed by the Pope.

Note: Boniface crowned Pepin King of the Franks.  Pepin was the son of Charles "the Hammer" Martel and father of Charlemagne (Charles the Great).  Pepin, Charles "The Hammer", and Charlemagne were the forefathers of the Carolingian Empire, from which, I assume, is where all names (state, people) containing "Carolina" is derived. 


Source: Charlemagne by Richard Winston

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Man's place in the universe...