Plato is known for promoting governance by philosopher-kings rather than direct democracy. He say corrupt, debased men casting votes for a society should be ruled, and he saw these same men kill his beloved Socrates, and so it is not surprising he favors autocracy by the those with the most merit.
When arguing his point, Plato (Book VI of The Republic) uses the analogy of a ship and the decision of who will command the ship. One option is to allow the captain, who has spent his life studying navigation and gaining years of actual experience. Another is the mass of sailors guiding the ship by mob, voting or even fighting to decide whether to turn the rudder or trim the mast. Certainly, you want the captain in charge, and the sailor subordinate to him.
Plato is making the case for central planning...or is he. Is he instead talking about the formation of laws? That is, is the captain a metaphor for a central planner or an enlightened lawmaker? I doubt Plato believed the philosopher-king should set prices, or should he? I don't know, but I think the ship-metaphor can be deciphered a number of ways, and to support a variety of politics.
Someone who wanted to study Plato and write something interesting could recast the ship-metaphor, making it reflect much of the elements of the calculation debates (calculation, meaning how can you plan without market prices to guide you?).
And tell him he is quite right in saying that the finest philosophers are useless to the multitude; but tell him it is their fault for not using them...
--Plato, The Republic, Book VI
- It is hard to feel special as a person in a univer...
- (IP) Why you should never try to pick stocks
- The Meaning of Life and It's Determinants
- The desire for philosopher-kings
- Great Intelligence Squared Debate About U.S. and C...
- More writers than readers
- How much education is optimal?
- The Essence of Anarchy
- Have you noticed?
- How science really works
- Independent Thinking, Helped
- Quote regarding alienated labor
- The Consequence of Karl Marx
- I just can't let this go...
- The Journal of Personality and Social Psychology i...
- College students don't learn anything
- Two contrasting views on property
- Plato's remarks about fiction
- I recommend watching "Fall of the Eagles"
- Excerpt from book review about economic growth
- Revising Plato's Ship
- Quote about Ph.D's and writing
- Lines from movie: Catherine the Great
- Two instances of altruism
- Why we coerce
- The Role of Activists and Information
- This guy doesn't understand prophecy (or, maybe I ...
- Meaning of Life: Hindu Perspective
- The March of Science
- What is intellectual progress (Cahoone quote)?
- What is philosophy (Cahoone quote)?
- The Meaning of Life (Prelude to thirty-six lectures)
- My Final Thoughts on Modern Philosophy
- Things People Never Say
- My place in the cosmos
- A Leap of Scientific Belief
- How Science Works, according to Thomas Kuhn...
- I do not accept the alternative, but I reject the ...
- Epistemic Holism
- Napoleon Bonaparte Quotes
- Conservatives in the Academia
- Importance of the Divine (and Stories) in Battle
- Ancient Seeds and Seed Banks
- Money and Happiness
- Fraud in Science
- The invention of logarithms
- The Death of Philosophy
- defending defending Bailey fffLLL
- testing testing Bailely testing
- Tips for Economic Arguments (Tip 1)
- ▼ March (53)
- ► 2009 (71)