This afternoon, my graduate student Lacey Seibert is giving her Master's Thesis defense. Her thesis concerns the cost of producing hogs under what many call improved animal welfare. A video of one of those "humane" farms can be viewed here. Compare that video to what traditional farms look like in the picture below.
Her results show that it costs $0.10 more per pound of live-hog (a hog ready for slaughter) under these higher welfare standards than in the traditional confinement farm shown above. Since one pound of live hog produces only 0.58 lbs of meat for the consumer (source), these higher welfare standards raise the cost of retail meat production by $0.1/0.58 = 0.17.*
Consequently, consumers would have to pay $0.17 more at the grocery store to provide hogs with a more content life. I think the current retail price of pork is about $3,** so this is an increase in pork prices of 0.17/3 = 6%. Anything wrong with this line of logic?
However, the farmer in the video seems to be claiming "antibiotic free". Many farmers who receive a premium due to the nonuse of antibiotics often deny antibiotics to sick pigs. That is not good stewardship. Organic farmers often provide poorer animal feeds, which leads to higher mortality rates. That is not good stewardship of animals either.
*Let Qf and Qr be the farm and retail quantity of pork. By definition, Qr= 0.58Qf, or Qf = Qr/0.58. The $0.1 per lb increase in costs raises meat costs by $0.1Qf = $0.1Qr/0.58, assuming that costs is passed onto the consumer in full. The per retail lb of this cost increase then equals ($0.1Qr/0.58)/Qr = $0.1/0.58 = $0.17.
**The current live hog futures price is $0.55 per lb of live hog, which is $0.55/0.58 = 0.95 per retail lb. For every dollar the consumer pays, the farmer receives $0.3. Thus, if the farmer receives close to $1 per retail lb, the consumer must be paying close to $3 per retail lb.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Blog Archive
-
▼
2008
(155)
-
▼
November
(67)
- 2008 AGEC 4213 Nerd of the Year!
- Trust Me: I'm Good For It
- Encyclopedia of Economic and Business History
- Green Energy
- Interesting Ag Facts
- Interesting Ag Facts
- Explaining Price Indices
- Beef, Pork, Chicken, and Egg Consumption: 1910-2006
- Corn and Gasoline Prices
- The Great Depression - Maybe We Learned Something
- Keynesian Perspective
- With Real Poets, It is Hard To Tell
- Ag Career Info
- Why Neoclassical Theory is Important
- It is more than that...
- Don't Forget...
- King Camp Gillette: Hero of Capitalism
- Gains From Trade...And Love
- The Importance of Insurance
- Oklahoma where the wind comes sweeping down the pl...
- Hereos of Capitalism
- Bird Spectacles
- Farm Animal Welfare: A Rare Statement of Truth
- Turkey Torture
- Explaining "Stimulus Package" to Students
- The Cow Tax
- The Market for Organic Eggs
- For Misplaced Southerners
- The Utility of Positive Emotion
- The Great Depression - We Learned Nothing
- Politically [un]Popular Ethanol
- Food Tales
- An Omnivore's Solution
- Cage Versus Cage Free
- The Cost of Happy Hogs
- The Importance of Economics
- Interesting Ag Facts
- American Socialism
- QLD livestock producers support fine increase
- Why Not Just Say "Farmer"
- The Pitfalls of Organic Food
- The Indifference Principle - In Practice
- Beef Prices in the 80's
- Broom Corn
- I, Broom
- Hello From Detroit
- God is Dead
- Laissez-Faire Higher Ed
- Secretary of Ag Michael Pollan
- The Fatal Conceit
- Steven Horwitz's An Open Letter to my Friends on t...
- We may begin hearing increased support for a bailo...
- Cattle, Hog, and Egg Prices: 1920-2002
- Steinbeck Talks About Food
- Sophistry
- Horrible Ideas
- Thinking About Graduate School?
- Economists Are Brilliant!!!!
- Thinking Like An Economist
- Picking Winners
- An Overview of the Agribusiness Degree
- Financial Crisis and Lending to the Poor
- Becoming a Great Teacher: Part 8
- We are all Socialists (1/3, at least)
- Trading Class Notes
- Humbling the Professor
- A New Approach to M.S. Theses
-
▼
November
(67)