Recent environmental activists have been proposing that Michael Pollan* be appointed Secretary of Agriculture. They don't seriously think it could happen, but just the thought excites them. (example here)
My impression is that they believe should Pollan become Secretary of Ag, he would take actions to force individuals into something closer to veganism. Pollan described to a large readership that much of the grains we grow are fed to animals, before fed to us, producing what he calls large amounts of waste. Since economic activity naturally uses fossil fuels, this "waste" is a contributor towards global warming.
This group of activists believe that if I decide to pay the added costs of fossil fuels (e.g. more fertilizer, more gasoline), to convert corn into beef, instead of eating corn, that I am committing an environmental crime. They wish to dictate in certain terms how fossil fuels are used to produce the goods that I consume.
I prefer an alternative philosophy. Fossil fuels are used in everything, to produce different goods for different people. Some people use more of those fuels than others, and they consequently pay a higher price the more of those fuels they use. Instead of dictating to people how they use fossil fuels, try to price fossil fuels right, and let people choose the goods (including food) that they prefer to eat.
Also, consider this thought. Suppose that we forgo meat consumption, using less land, fuels, fertilizer, and hence fossil fuels to produce our food. We save lots of money in the process through a lower grocery bill. We will certainly spend that extra money. How do we know these "other" things purchased will not use more fossil fuels than the meat we once ate?
* If you are not aware, Michael Pollan is a talented story teller who writes about food. His book The Omnivores Dilemma attempts to describe why the "true" costs of our food is not apparent at the grocery store. His understanding of markets and social coordination is poor, but then, he is not an economist. For a superb and fair critique of the book, see this one by George Mason economist Tyler Cowen.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Blog Archive
-
▼
2008
(155)
-
▼
November
(67)
- 2008 AGEC 4213 Nerd of the Year!
- Trust Me: I'm Good For It
- Encyclopedia of Economic and Business History
- Green Energy
- Interesting Ag Facts
- Interesting Ag Facts
- Explaining Price Indices
- Beef, Pork, Chicken, and Egg Consumption: 1910-2006
- Corn and Gasoline Prices
- The Great Depression - Maybe We Learned Something
- Keynesian Perspective
- With Real Poets, It is Hard To Tell
- Ag Career Info
- Why Neoclassical Theory is Important
- It is more than that...
- Don't Forget...
- King Camp Gillette: Hero of Capitalism
- Gains From Trade...And Love
- The Importance of Insurance
- Oklahoma where the wind comes sweeping down the pl...
- Hereos of Capitalism
- Bird Spectacles
- Farm Animal Welfare: A Rare Statement of Truth
- Turkey Torture
- Explaining "Stimulus Package" to Students
- The Cow Tax
- The Market for Organic Eggs
- For Misplaced Southerners
- The Utility of Positive Emotion
- The Great Depression - We Learned Nothing
- Politically [un]Popular Ethanol
- Food Tales
- An Omnivore's Solution
- Cage Versus Cage Free
- The Cost of Happy Hogs
- The Importance of Economics
- Interesting Ag Facts
- American Socialism
- QLD livestock producers support fine increase
- Why Not Just Say "Farmer"
- The Pitfalls of Organic Food
- The Indifference Principle - In Practice
- Beef Prices in the 80's
- Broom Corn
- I, Broom
- Hello From Detroit
- God is Dead
- Laissez-Faire Higher Ed
- Secretary of Ag Michael Pollan
- The Fatal Conceit
- Steven Horwitz's An Open Letter to my Friends on t...
- We may begin hearing increased support for a bailo...
- Cattle, Hog, and Egg Prices: 1920-2002
- Steinbeck Talks About Food
- Sophistry
- Horrible Ideas
- Thinking About Graduate School?
- Economists Are Brilliant!!!!
- Thinking Like An Economist
- Picking Winners
- An Overview of the Agribusiness Degree
- Financial Crisis and Lending to the Poor
- Becoming a Great Teacher: Part 8
- We are all Socialists (1/3, at least)
- Trading Class Notes
- Humbling the Professor
- A New Approach to M.S. Theses
-
▼
November
(67)